Section Two
Values and Behavior in the Pagan Community


This section is divided into three parts. The first deals with the Pagan view of the Universe, and looks at the subjects of time, space, and the causes of change. The second section deals the Pagan view of truth, and covers the topics of relativity, and sensuality as a source for inspiration and spirituality. The last of these three sections discusses the Pagan view of relationships, and looks into the issues of anarchy, community, and acceptance.


PART 1 - A PAGAN VIEW OF THE UNIVERSE

This first part of a study in the Pagan value system is divided up into the worldview of the average Neo-Pagan on these issues: Time, space, and causes of change in the universe. The Pagan philosophy on these issues is critical in understanding some basic worldview assumptions within Pagan culture.

TIME

The concept of time in the Neo-Pagan world view is cyclical. The celebration of the sabbats, and the belief in reincarnation (almost universal among Neo-Pagans) both illustrate this clearly.

Samhain (Halloween) is considered both the beginning, and the end of the sabbat (holy day) celebrations. Like New Year' Eve, it is the celebration of the transition from the end to the beginning of the Celtic New Year which begins on November 1st. Together there are eight Witches' sabbats which represent a cycle of birth, life, death, and rebirth. These are viewed as an ongoing cycle which mirror the transitions within an individual's life.

Starhawk wrote of this cycle in her book The Spiral Dance,


"Winter, Spring, Summer, Autumn - birth, growth, fading, death - the Wheel turns, on and on. Ideas are born; projects consummated; plans prove impractical and die. We fall in love; we suffer loss; we consummate relationships; we give birth; we grow old ; we decay.... As we enact each drama in its time, we transform ourselves. We are renewed; we are reborn even as we decay and die...."3


The Pagan sabbats represent a cyclical view of time, and a belief system which offers repeated opportunities of growth through reincarnation. As the wheel of the sabbats turns, the Pagan celebrates conception, birth, growth, decay, death, and rebirth, and see these as representative of their own existence.

TIME, REINCARNATION, AND A DIFFERENT VIEW OF LIFE


The belief in reincarnation is almost universal in Neo-Pagan thought. This belief gives the Pagan a different view of life, and death than that to which we might be accustomed.

Unlike the Christian view of death, which sees death as a curse, and as an enemy, and an end to the life of an individual (unless one has been redeemed, and is guaranteed the promise of eternal life), the Pagan view of death is that it is merely another part of life - a continuation of the cycle of life, death, and rebirth.

Starhawk speaks of the ritual which reenacts the death of the horned God, and gives this insight on the Pagan understanding of life and death,

"...But in a world view that sees everything as cyclical, death itself cannot be the final ending, but rather some unknown transformation to some new form of being. In enacting and reenacting the death of the God, we prepare ourselves for that transformation, to live out the last stage of life."4

The following discussion with Marsha (Stargazer) also highlights this thinking:

Q: "What occurs at death, and how do you know when death actually occurs? Does this soul who has lived a long life on earth also go back to the Cauldron of Rebirth?"

A: "Most Pagans accept the medical view of death for legal reasons as being the cessation of brain activity. That is usually when a person is taken off a respirator and allowed to completely die. For our Tradition, the last breath is when the soul departs the body, although we also accept that the soul stays around usually for anywhere from 3 -7 days after death before going on to the Summerland or Cauldron of Rebirth where it takes lessons learned in this life and plots the course of the next life. The Summerland/Cauldron is where all souls go to become young again and await rebirth to be with their loved ones again."

SPACE

Within Neo-Pagan ritual, space takes on powerful references. The circle is of prime importance in Wiccan ritual. As the circle is cast, it is believed to hold within its sphere (or cone as some would call it) the corporate powers which are raised during the ritual. By the use of the will, space is created or manipulated to become sacred.

Although it is believed that all nature is sacred, there is special significance to the casting of the circle. Within the circle there is a greater potentiality than without.

To illustrate this, I witnessed one Pagan walk around his car three times to cast a protectionary circle about it, when he parked.

The calling of the quarters also illustrates the pagan view of sacred space. The powers which come from the east, the south, the west, and the north are called into the circle at the beginning of a ritual. From the directions of the map, the powers of nature are called to take up residence, and work within the sacred space of the circle during the ritual.

After attending a weekend camping trip, and ritual celebration with about 30 Neo-Pagans, I discussed the implications of the circle with Olwen, I also asked about the power of the circle, and this is what she had to say:

"In casting a circle, a sphere of energy is created which serves as a seal so that the energy which is raised inside is contained and therefore intensified, much the same way a pressure cooker intensifies the energy applied from the outside, but [is] contained inside. In addition the sphere keeps out unwanted influences."
SACRED SPACE AND THE POWER OF MANIPULATION

Aleister Crowley defined magic as, "the Science and Art of causing change to occur in conformity to Will." This definition shows the centrality of the manipulation of power to The Craft. Just as the Pagan believes sacred space can be created by drawing, or walking in a circle, and directing the human will to make that space sacred, so it is believed that the rest of creation can potentially be manipulated through the use of the human will.

This manipulation of space, and even of the resources of nature are at the heart of Witchcraft. Without this belief in the ability to manipulate space (and also natural forces, as shall be seen later), there is no basis for spell casting, and ritual in Neo-Paganism.

CAUSE OF CHANGE

The Neo-Pagan world view is primarily an evolutionary one. The stories of the gods and goddesses tend to be understood as myths, and for this reason are not considered absolute statements for either the creation, or the beginning of life. Thus, evolution as taught in our schools of higher learning tends to be the accepted belief for the origin of the universe. Behind this evolution lies a force called by some "God." This God may be either personal or impersonal.

MYSTICAL EVOLUTION AND A SENSE OF RESPONSIBILITY

This view of origins also gives us an understanding of the Pagan view of growth. The hope, and the goal of the Neo-Paganism is to grow as one merges with the forces of nature, the Goddess, or "Gaia" (a term for "Mother Earth," or Nature - understood to be a creative power). Creation evolved, and each person has the potential to evolve as well.

This is a mystical view of evolution. It is not an evolution which occurs by mere chance, rather it is an evolution directed by the magical forces of nature. Personal growth is a result of acting in agreement with these forces.

Within this view of a mystical evolution, there is a belief in reaping the results of your own doings. It is understood to be a law of the universe. This law is called the Three-fold Law. Whatever one does will be returned upon him three times as much again, and in like kind. Thus, the cause of our own calamities, or blessings are the direct result of our own deeds. Inherent in this view is a deep sense of responsibility.

PART 2 - A PAGAN VIEW OF TRUTH

THE RELATIVITY FACTOR

In the Pagan view of truth, morality and theology are relative. Relative to a situation, to an individual, and to a season in time.


RELATIVITY IN THEOLOGY


In my first visit to a large gathering of Pagans, I discovered that there was a variety of beliefs. This was celebrated. Quickly I learned that relativism in theology was a primary theme of Neo-Pagan culture.

Many of the Pagans present at this weekend gathering, had pointed out that theological relativity was a celebrated thing in Pagan culture. Olwen, who organized the event did not believe in teaching people "what to believe." Ivan, from The Church of Amazement considered himself a Trinitarian, but thought he was the only person in his group who viewed God in this way. For Ivan, all the Pagan myths of other cultures, and all the names, and stories of the Gods and Goddesses of other cultures, just gave a clearer picture of the nature of the his God.

RELATIVITY IN RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE

Ritual experience is also influenced by relativity. It is not the truth learned through experience, which is of the greatest value. That truth is relative, and is good for the one experiencing it. In fact, spiritual experiences do not necessarily have to provide insight to truth. They are valid as subjective experiences all on their own.

Neither does Pagan spiritual experience necessarily call a person to allegiance to a God or Goddess.

Allegiance is the result of a absolutist system. Often practices, and rituals affirm the Neo-Pagan's trust in relativity, and help devalue absolute systems of thought.

In the Goddess Chant, the chorus repeats the names of Pagan Goddesses, "Isis, Astarte, Diana, Hecate, Demeter, Kali, Innana." The general understanding being, that these are all names relating to one feminine force, or Goddess. Thus, the myths of the Pagan Goddesses of many cultures are understood to relate to oneีs own definition of the "Goddess."

Myth and story interpretation, which is a large part of the Pagan experience, is also determined by this value of relativism. In the mind of many Pagans, the myths of the Pagan culture can not be viewed as truths, they are stories filled with meanings to help one discover themselves, and to discover the secrets of The Craft. I have found that the individual Neo-Pagan will usually swap stories, even with the Christian, without feeling threatened, after all, the story's definition is determined by what the individual gets out of it.

Personal Guidance is also influenced by this value of relativity. Each person finds guidance in a way personally chosen. Some will seek a mentor, some a book, and some will discover guidance through a ritual. There is no specific rule for guidance.

The totality of the Pagan spiritual experience is ruled by this relativity factor.

RELATIVITY AND MORALITY

The effect of relativity upon theology and spiritual experience is just the beginning of its effect in the individual life. It touches upon every area of experience for the Neo-Pagan.

The area of life most touched upon perhaps, is morality. Morality does not really exist in Neo-Pagan thought. Paganism is an amoral system. There are ethics, but they tend to be situationally determined. As a result, the primary taboo of Pagan culture is intolerance. After all, this is what relativity teaches, that everything is okay. Which then tells us that anything which teaches that everything is not okay, is in itself not okay.

In a lengthy discussion with a group from The Church of Amazement, on the nature of sin and whether it existed, I heard these views for relativism from many in the group. The primary assumption was that the moral codes of Christianity were arbitrary rules, and thereby were frustrating. Not only were the laws seen as frustrating, but they gave evidence of a capricious, and cruel God.

Olwen (a Wiccan high priestess) and I were playing darts. It was Lammas, and competitive game playing was a part of the celebration of the day. She threw her darts toward the board, and narrowly missed the bullseye. As she stepped aside to let me have my turn, I said, "You know what it's called when you miss the bullseye like that, don't you?" I was actually testing the waters on a subject close to the core of my Christian worldview. "No, what is it called?" she responded. "Sin." I said. I proceeded to explain the definition for both a Hebrew, and a Greek word for "sin," which has for its meaning, "missing the mark." "Oh, I am so glad I do not believe in sin. That is such a harsh definition." she remarked, rather forcefully.

This little encounter illustrates this primary difference between the Pagan, and the Christian community. The Pagan world is relativistic.

THE SENSUALITY FACTOR

The Pagan desire for sensuality is deeper than sexual gratification. This is a fundamental part of the Pagan experience. The five senses are primary sources of energy, and personal spiritual experience.

When I began my study in American Paganism, this issue was one I was perhaps the most uncomfortable with. My initial thoughts ran along these lines: 1) That Pagan sensuality was a wholly sexual issue. 2) I was uncomfortable with the thought of being around such an influence. 3) My judgment was that it was an excuse for uncontrolled passion, on the part of many men, and women in The Craft.

These are the things I discovered: 1) It is an issue which moves into the heart of the Pagan way, and covers a large part of life from spiritual experiences, to sexuality, to determining one's morality. 2) Although I am not careless around this influence, I do not view this sensuality as an always threatening attack. Yet, I have an increased sensitivity to the potential powerful influence in this arena. 3) My judgment concerning this now is, that this sensuality has a higher degree of influence over the belief system of the Pagan than I previously understood.

The myth of creation reiterated below shows us that sensuality is a key component of Neo-Pagan ritual and practice.

One myth of the Goddess is this:

Before all things there was the Goddess. Alone, awesome, complete within herself. She looked into the curved mirror of dark space, saw her reflection and fell in love with herself. By her power she drew it forth, and made love with herself. She called it "Miria the Wonderful."

Their ecstasy brought forth all that is, or was, or ever shall be. The Goddess became filled, and then swollen with love, and she birthed the bright spots which became all living beings.

But in that great moment Miria was swept away. As she moved away from the Goddess she became more masculine. First, she became the Blue God - gentle laughing, full of love; then the Green One, mighty, rooted in the earth, the spirit of all living things; then the Horned God, ruddy yet with the face of death. But always desire draws him back to the Goddess, always circling her, seeking to return to his love.

Just as sensuality, and self love were the source of creative force in the Goddess in this myth, so sensuality, and self love are root values of Paganism today. Experience, not fact is the source of inspiration. Ritual, not faith is the path of the practitioner. Freedom to experience is the necessary tenet of the system. So it is that the Wiccan Rede ends, "...do what thou wilt."

Olwen spoke of experiencing a sense of rising, and ebbing spiritual energy as the group released their corporate energies through chants and dances.

In the practice of ritual, many Pagans reach for the experience of the ecstatic. There is a desire for reaching an emotional point which creates joy, peace, or some point of personal release. This is often viewed as the high point of ritual experience. People at the Lammas festival I attended, responded verbally to the ecstatic sensations of their spiritual experiences.

In concluding the thoughts on this section we learn that, sensual experience is a high point of Pagan experience. The Pagan worldview is understood from this ritual pattern. This worldview says that sensuality is good. Any cultural condemnation of sensuality(i.e the 10 commandments), or exploitation of it (i.e. pornography) tends to be rejected.

PART 2 - A PAGAN VIEW OF RELATIONSHIPS


THE ANARCHY FACTOR

Anarchy is a fundamental theme of paganism. In Montague Summers' 1925 publishing of The History of Witchcraft, he restates theories and definitions of Witchcraft from the middle ages. The first words of the book establishes this theme of anarchy, as he opens with the words of Jean Bodin in his work De la Demonomanie des Sorciers, "A sorcerer is one who by commerce with the Devil has full intention of attaining his own ends."5 This opens the book, and the first chapter which is called, "The Witch: Heretic and Anarchist." What is worthy of note in these first words of the book is the connection with Witchcraft and anarchy early in this century. Margot Adler also identifies anarchy as an embraced value of Paganism. (Drawing Down the Moon pg.180)

This was one of the first values I came across as I began to study Neo-Paganism more closely. This is how I thought and felt: 1) I simply viewed it as a response for self rule, and a desire to do one's "own thing." 2) I felt that it had highly selfish overtones.

My thoughts and attitudes have changed in these ways: 1) I see the anarchist trend as a response to poor, and demanding leadership from previous generations. Religious, political, and family leaders who required obedience without giving reasons, helped to create an understandable "knee-jerk" response which has the taken the form of anarchy. 2) The heart of self rule is the desire for self fulfillment. This can be highly selfish, but not always so.

As noted earlier, the baby boomer's response of flocking to the many cultic systems which were birthed out of the late sixties, was in part due to the search for freedom. Freedom redefined in modern terminology is, "Do your own thing." This is anarchy defined.


ANARCHY AS REBELION AND CREATIVITY

Although it is a simple thing to quickly see the negative aspects of anarchy, there are positive things which have grown out of this cultural transformation as well.

On the negative side, we understand that anarchy requires rebellion towards any form of law, or authority to which an individual does not freely offer their allegiance. In the case of absolute values of right and wrong (which of course the Pagan usually does not recognize), rebellion to these forces is viewed as acceptable, and sometimes even applauded.

On the positive side, freedom results in creativity. There has been a backlash against the empty creeds, and the strict dogmas, and the dry rituals of many so-called Christian churches. The search for meaning is a positive result of this anarchist rebellion. To see this search for freedom in only negative terms, is a naive response, which misses the deepest cry of the Pagan heart.

THE COMMUNITY FACTOR

Pagans view one another as being spiritually related. This community is one of the prime factors in holding Pagans together.

Community in Neo-Pagan culture is real and powerful. They are open, and warm people for the most part. I, personally have felt very welcomed by their acceptance. Despite the obvious points of disagreement which are fundamental issues between their worldview, and my own Christian worldview, I have been received in respect, and warmth in most cases.

In discussing this issue of Pagan community with Marsha, a Wiccan priestess from Los Angeles, the subject of viewing the coven as a family was addressed:

Q: How would you define "family" in the context of the Pagan community? Is there a sense of family among Pagans, or does the radical individualism of the anarchic system reject the establishment of a "family of faith?"

A: ...In the larger Pagan and Wiccan community, we do tend to refer to each other as "siblings" or "sibs" in a very general sense... actually, we think of each other more like the American sense of "cousin". We are a very independent breed, but we also recognize our communality of spirit in a very generalized sense.

Q: It seems to me, that there is a clear sense of an extended family in Pagan circles. Is this the case, and if so, how would you define that extended family? What are the conditions which place an individual within the context of that family?

A: In my tradition, a coven is very much a spiritual family. Our rite of dedication (the first official step on the path to priest/esshood) contains words talking about ritual adoption as a part of the apprenticeship one is undertaking.

I would hesitate to define it any further than that. Many of my coven consider me their "clan mother" and our other 2nd and 3rd degree priest/esses as aunts and uncles in a way. We haven't considered yet working out any more specific kinship terms or organization than that since we tend to be somewhat egalitarian.

To be placed within the context of our spiritual family, one goes through apprenticeship (minimum study of a full year or more) followed by the ritual of initiation/ordination. One is not considered a "member" of the coven until one takes the oath of dedication, but we have many "friends of the coven" and "grove members" who semi-regularly attend rituals and sometimes actively participate in the creation and performance of Sabbat rituals.

COMMUNITY VERSES ANARCHY: A STUMBLING BLOCK TO GROWTH

Although community is high on the list of priorities of Pagan fellowship, it runs head first into a competing value in the Neo-Pagan value system - Anarchy. These two values oppose one another directly, and potentially force individual members of the Pagan community into mental or emotional incongruity.

When do you obey the directives of a Pagan leader, and when do you disobey for the sake of personal opinion or convenience? How does one choose between the betterment of self, and the betterment of another, when there appears to be no other option? At what point, if at any, does one surrender personal freedom for the benefit of a group?

These are common issues in community, and are not easily answered in the framework which equally honors both anarchy and community.

There are two levels at which these discordant principles work in opposition to growth.

The first level is that of personal growth. The greatest part of the process of growth and adaptation to society, and surrounding culture is relational. Learning to treat one another with respect, developing the skills of communication, and group decision making demands growth. A great deal of personal growth only occurs within community. Anarchy tends to work against this principle of community, and personal growth is hindered.

In the discussion with Marsha, it was clear that although the Paganism did develop a sense of community which feels like
" family," aggressive independence was still the order of the day. Reference to one another was with such terms as "sibs," and "cousins" was the term she used to give clarity to the connection. This is much less restrictive, and less responsible terminology than "brother," or "sister."

The second level at which these competing values hinder growth, is at the corporate level. The growth of local churches and covens is potentially hindered by this lack of congruence. Margot Adler references this tension in respect to the ritual practices of Neo-Pagans. As the religion continues to grow, there will be increasing opportunities for tension between those who practice a traditional form of witchcraft, and those who are more eclectic. She refers to this as the "creative tension."6

Theology, and ritual is just one element of this tension between community and anarchy in group dynamics. The more critical issue is that of tension in individual relationships. Relationships between leader and follower, husband and wife, initiate and mentor....

This Pagan world view in respect to people and groups is perhaps the most conflicting set of values which the Pagan is faced with. On one hand there is an open acceptance of all people (except perhaps those who hold absolute value systems), and on the other hand there is a rejection of all authority (except the authority of one's self). This conflicting value system is at the core of the eclectic, and fragile religion of the Neo-Pagan. At once, they are both drawn together by openness, and forced apart by their anarchist ways. For this reason the Neo-Pagan system may well always remain an underground system.

Small groups are the standard for gathering, but there is another way which many have chosen to follow. There is an increasingly growing number of "solitaries," (individual practicing Witches with no coven attachment) who do things exactly as they want, without the leadership of any (except perhaps the books they read, and the experiences they have.) The growth of the number of "solitaries" is likely a result of this value tension in the Pagan system.

THE ACCEPTANCE FACTOR

Acceptance from the society at large is often an important matter in the eyes of the Neo-Pagan. This is certainly not true for all, but I have found it to be a recurring theme in many relationships.

Some friends of mine from Salem are quite motivated by this desire. In my e-mail communications with them, I mentioned that I desired to break down the walls of prejudice which stood between the Pagan and Christian communities. My hope was to cause Christians to realize that "witches are real people too," and likewise to cause Pagans to realize that, "Christians are real people too." In the many e-mail letters I have sent, I have not received such a quick reply, with a hearty agreement, and a sense of excitement from the Pagan community as I did with that small, and simple statement. It touched on the sensitive issue of social acceptance.

ACCEPTANCE WITHIN THE CRAFT

In the previous section on community, there was a discussion with Marsha, a high priestess in Los Angeles. In the discussion which focused upon recognizing the coven as an extended family unit, some of the factors which give us understanding of a person's acceptance in Pagan circles was discussed.

Ritual and Education are a Basis for Acceptance. The common time frame within Wiccan circles, with which one must study in order to be initiated is "a year and a day." Marsha's coven appears to loosely follow this same format. With the accepted time of study, and the ritual initiation, one may become a full member of this family. Until this time, a person is considered a friend. Worthy of note, is that the coven utilizes words talking about "ritual adoption."

THE HISTORY OF WITCHCRAFT AND SOCIAL ACCEPTANCE

Perhaps the most recognized piece of history among Neo-Pagans has to do with the writing of James Sprenger, and Heinrich Kramer in the late 15th century. Its title was Malleus Maleficarum, or The Witches' Hammer.

An internet resource called "The Seminar on Witchcraft" has the following quote (from the paper titled "The Vulnerability of Women to Witchcraft Accusations": by Christian Day) concerning this time in history:

"The most harmful work of propaganda ever directed at women was the Malleus Mal[i]ficarum, or Witches' Hammer. This book set a standard of misogyny so great that Western civilization is still influenced by its hateful ideas. Written by Dominicans Jacob Sprenger and Heinrich Kra[e]mer and released in 1486 (with an official endorsement from Pope Innocent VIII), The 'Malleus' organized the many techniques used by the witch hunters into handbook form. The handbook was then widely distributed and relied upon by a great majority of the witch hunters."7

Shortly thereafter, a Papal Bull was released granting authority to try, and to execute witches. The Neo-Pagan is taught that this brought about what they call, "The Burning Times." During this time tens of thousands of people were tortured, or executed for the crime of witchcraft. On the European continent death was by burning often, in England it was by hanging.

Although there are scholars on the issue, such as Montague Summers' book, The History of Witchcraft, who would disagree with the Pagan understanding of the "Burning Times," it is accepted as written above in most Pagan circles.

This is one of the first things many initiates, and even searchers of Paganism hear about The Craft. As a result of this sensitivity to persecution, and the fact that Witchcraft is still a fearful concept to many Westerners, Pagan leaders have led the charge for social acceptance over the last 20 years, with such organizations as The Witches' League for Public Awareness, and the Pagan Awareness League.


ANARCHY, RELATIVISM, AND SOCIAL ACCEPTANCE

The individual Pagan may have struggles for social acceptance beyond the issue of their involvement with The Craft. Relativism has created the adoption of practices outside the social norm, and many people living alternative, or socially "unacceptable" lifestyles have found refuge in Neo-Paganism.

Margot Adler outlines the growth of the gay Pagan movement, and the much larger and highly influential feminist's movement within Neo-Pagan culture. The Craft has become a haven for many people seeking social acceptance. The community value of Pagan culture has offered needed sanctuary for those who feel socially rejected.

Despite being a place of refuge for those seeking acceptance, The Craft itself remains an outsider to full social acceptance. Some people are comfortable with this, others struggle.

In a negative sense, there is a degree of identity earned from this social struggle: It is not what you are, or who you are descended from, which establishes true personal identity, but rather, it seems that there is a good degree of respect given to those who live outside the social norms peacefully. Alternative sexuality is the primary example of this. Those who practice lifestyles variant from the social norm, are applauded as courageous warriors on the field of life.

This identity may become a vicious circle, unfortunately. The more one practices socially rejected lifestyle activities, the more they become protected, and applauded by the Pagan community. Yet, even as this occurs, the Pagan community at large moves further away from the social norm, and the individual finds themselves being applauded in one world, and rejected in another.

The result is that many Pagans are living in radical dichotomy. They do not let it be known in their place of work, or even among their families, that they are Witches. They take on names which they use within The Craft, and this may be the only place they utilize that name. Only those with whom they feel comfortable may actually know both names. This dichotomy is not unlike many socially alternative lifestyle choices. At the heart of this choice to divide their lives into such compartments, may be a simple, and understandable defense for personal safety, or a more complex desire for social acceptance.

Introduction    Section 1      Section 3     Section 4     Bibliography
To Call    To Teach     To Heal    To Reach    Home